Below is the list of Jefferson basketball players selected with All-State Honors. Congratulations to the following J-Hawks.
| 1st Team | ||
| Al Jenkins | 1964-65 | Guard |
| Larry Baker | 1966-67 | Center |
| BJ Trickey | 1966-67 | Guard |
| Brad Trickey | 1970-71 | Guard |
| Dean Uthoff | 1975-76 | Center |
| Cam Johnson | 1988-89 | Guard |
| Tory Meiborg | 1992-93 | Guard |
| Jackson Jones | 1996-97 | Forward |
| Jackson Jones | 1997-98 | Forward |
| Claudell Mims | 1998-99 | Guard |
| Brandon Sain | 1999-00 | Forward |
| Bryant Kucera | 2005-06 | Forward |
| 2nd Team | ||
| Dave Long | 1961-62 | Forward |
| Tom Mullin | 1968-69 | Forward |
| Tom Holland | 1969-70 | Center |
| Colin Mattiace | 1991-92 | Center |
| Steve Ulrich | 1993-94 | Forward |
| Bruce Sain | 1997-98 | Forward |
| Claudell Mims | 1999-00 | Guard |
| 3rd Team | ||
| Larry Lawrence | 1966-67 | Guard |
| Jeff High | 1979-80 | Forward |
| Tory Meiborg | 1991-92 | Guard |
| Nick Nordgren | 2004-05 | Guard |
| Chad Underwood | 2007-08 | Forward |
| 4th Team | ||
| Al Jenkins | 1963-64 | Guard |
| Jim Nance | 1966-67 | Forward |
| Ed Uthoff | 1967-68 | Forward |
| Rusty Hamilton | 1971-72 | Forward |
| Mike Ivester | 1985-86 | Center |